Abnormal toxicity test removal
Law & Regulation
In Effect
July 15, 2021
Summary
South Korea’s Ministry of Food and Drug Safety amended its biologicals standard and test-method guidelines to remove the Abnormal Toxicity Test (ATT) as a required batch quality control test for vaccines and other biological products, announcing the change on 15 July 2021.
The Animal-Free Safety Assessment Collaboration’s international tracking records South Korea’s deletion as having entered into force in 2022. ATT previously required injecting mice and guinea pigs with multiple human doses of a biological product to observe abnormal reactions; manufacturers of MFDS-regulated vaccines and biologicals are no longer required to perform this test for batch release.
Background Context
ATT had been maintained as a standard batch-release requirement in pharmacopoeias and national regulations for decades despite accumulating scientific evidence questioning its reliability for detecting quality or safety issues. The World Health Organization’s Expert Committee on Biological Standardization recommended in 2018 that ATT be removed from The International Pharmacopoeia and WHO vaccine and biologicals recommendations.
Multiple other jurisdictions, including the European Pharmacopoeia, United States, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, and India, had already deleted or partially deleted ATT before or during the period leading to South Korea’s change. In December 2020, South Korea’s National Assembly introduced the Act on the Promotion of Development, Dissemination and Use of Alternatives to Animal Testing Method, providing a legal framework for reviewing and eliminating redundant animal-based regulatory tests.
Humane Society International/Korea, working under a Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation grant, engaged with Korean regulatory authorities and industry stakeholders as part of a broader program to eliminate redundant animal-based regulatory tests, within the wider context of the Animal-Free Safety Assessment Collaboration’s international program targeting ATT deletion across jurisdictions.
System Impact
Direction
Reduces Exploitation
Type
Alters Legal Basis
Significance
Moderate
Following the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety’s 15 July 2021 announcement, ATT is no longer included as a required batch quality control test in MFDS biologicals standard and test-method guidelines for vaccines and other biological products. Manufacturers of MFDS-regulated vaccines and biologicals are no longer required to plan, conduct, or report ATT as a condition of batch release under the amended regulation.
The Animal-Free Safety Assessment Collaboration’s international status tracking records South Korea’s ATT requirement as “Deleted (2022),” referencing the same amendment to the Regulation on Approval and Review of Biologicals Products. No quantitative data on the number of animals, batches, or facilities affected by the deletion is available in current sourcing.
Anticipated Effects
If manufacturers replace ATT with non-animal or other quality-assurance approaches as encouraged by WHO and Animal-Free Safety Assessment Collaboration guidance, some quality-control activities for biologicals would be expected to shift toward analytical, process-validation, or in vitro methods. This is a conditional expectation; available sources do not document post-implementation data on the degree to which testing has shifted to alternative methods or on realized reductions in the number of mice and guinea pigs used for this purpose in South Korea since the deletion.
Significance Rationale
Assigned Reduces Exploitation because the amendment documents an actual, completed deletion of a previously mandatory in vivo animal test from national batch-release requirements for biological products, rather than a stated intention or future target; ATT’s removal directly eliminates a specific, defined use of mice and guinea pigs from the regulatory testing system.
Assigned Alters Legal Basis as the primary mechanism, since the amendment changes what is legally required for batch quality control of biological products by deleting ATT from the mandated test panel, rather than adjusting operational conditions within a continuing test requirement.
Assigned Moderate significance because the deletion applies across an entire national regulatory category (batch release testing for MFDS-regulated vaccines and biologicals) but addresses a single specific test rather than the broader landscape of animal testing in pharmaceutical and chemical regulation, and no quantitative data on the number of animals previously used in ATT in South Korea is available to establish the scale of this reduction. The duration and persistence of this change is not established in available sources, though no reversal, suspension, or legal challenge has been identified.
Within The System
Key Actors
The Ministry of Food and Drug Safety issued the amendment to the biologicals standard and test-method guidelines and administers the Regulation on Approval and Review of Biologicals Products under which ATT was deleted. The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea provided a broader legal framework for reviewing and eliminating redundant animal-based regulatory tests through the December 2020 Act on the Promotion of Development, Dissemination and Use of Alternatives to Animal Testing Method. Humane Society International/Korea, represented in public communications by Senior Policy Manager Borami Seo, engaged with regulatory authorities on the deletion under a Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation grant. The World Health Organization’s Expert Committee on Biological Standardization and the Animal-Free Safety Assessment Collaboration provided the international scientific and coordination context informing the change.
Notice an inaccuracy or omission?
If you believe information on this page is incorrect, incomplete, or missing important context, you may submit a suggested correction for review.